I know I spend a lot of time on this blog talking about how little I like romance novels. The truth is, though, that I actually like romance quite a lot when it is done well and when it is a secondary storyline in a larger story that is about something else. If a relationship is well-developed and populated by two characters who both have other things going on… I can be as big a shipper as anyone. As such, I’m not above being devastated when my favorite fictional relationships don’t turn out the way I think that they should.
Unlike books, which usually have one author, TV shows have a lot of moving parts. A whole team of writers, actors, networks, producers, etc. work together to create one collective story. Sometimes something that is lovingly set up just can’t follow through in TV world. Sometimes one person starts something and leaves it in the hands of someone else, someone who has a very different idea of what should happen. Sometimes a contract expires and and an actor leaves at an inopportune time. Sometimes everything goes entirely to plan and the plan is not what I wanted. These shows spurred me to make a list of my favorite TV couples who, if I’d been in charge, absolutely would have been each other’s happily ever after. In some cases, I ultimately agree that the writers made the right choices. In others, I respect the decision but disagree with it. In still others, I’m legitimately mad about the way things ended up because I think that the breakups ultimately betrayed more than just the fictional couple.
I started this post months ago, right after Supernatural‘s impressively horrific excuse for an ending. I figured I would let this sit for a while so that I could reassess and tone it down if time had mellowed my anger. Spoiler alert: it hasn’t. That one makes me mad. A couple others on this list make me mad. Some I begrudgingly understand. One I really respect and think the writers made the right choice.
In any case, this was a lot of fun, and here are my 10 TV Couples Who Should’ve Ended Up Together (with two honorable mentions for additional pairings in a show that’s already been mentioned). So, in no particular order, here we go!
Oh… spoilers for Crazy Ex-Girlfriend, Downton Abbey, Friends, Game of Thrones, Gilmore Girls, Grey’s Anatomy, How I Met Your Mother, The Office, Schitt’s Creek, and Supernatural.
Sybil Crowley and Tom Branson, Downton Abbey
![](https://telltaletv.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/12/tumblr_5f4922e1d0292f96dc3f0bf146180c3d_d4627842_540.gif)
Why didn’t they end up together? They fell in love and got married! They were living happily ever after (relatively, anyway, considering their politics and the situation in Ireland), but Sybil died in childbirth. More to the point, Jessica Brown Findlay’s contract ran out and she wanted to leave the show so she had to be written out. Actor contracts really plagued Downton Abbey (*cough Matthew cough*).
What’s their deal? Downton Abbey is full of romances, but this is the one that really worked for me. It helps that Sybil was my favorite character long before Tom arrived on the scene. The youngest daughter of the Crowley family, she was independent and self-actualized in ways her older sisters—so focused on petty rivalries and romance—weren’t. Unlike the rest of the family, she looked beyond the privilege of obscene wealth and became socially conscious. She worked for women’s rights and volunteered as a nurse during the war because doing so was the right thing to do. Tom was the only person who really understood these passions. He supported her activism and encouraged her to walk her own path instead of bowing to her family’s traditionalism. Their politics weren’t necessarily identical, but they were both dedicated to eschewing the way things were for the way they could be. And while the servant falls for the rich girl he works for is far from an uncommon storyline, it works really well with Sybil and Tom because it demonstrates their ability to overcome class bias. Basically, they’re two matched souls who found each other in a society that really didn’t want them together, and they encouraged each other to reach their full potential.
It was really sad when Sybil died. Her actual death was very well written and acted, but it was devastating. Like I said, Sybil was my favorite character and Sybil/Tom was my favorite romance, so it was rough to lose them both in one fell swoop. It was even harder when, in the following season, the show kept trying to replace her. It kept bringing in spunky, forward-thinking girls and throwing them at Tom because, I guess, it didn’t know what to do with him without her. And it felt pretty disrespectful to Sybil, especially since all the potential girlfriends were clearly meant to be like her. Making Tom fall in love with anyone but Sybil was going to be a tough pill to swallow regardless of who it was, but trying to recreate Sybil was the wrong call. Also one of those spunky, forward-thinking girls raped Tom and the show just kinda shrugged it off, so…
The show went sharply downhill after Sybil (and Matthew) left. I can’t lay the quality dip entirely at the feet of Sybil’s death, but it certainly didn’t help. Downton Abbey eventually got it back together and I really enjoyed the end of the show and the reunion movie, but IMO Downton Abbey’s glory days are still season two, when Sybil and Branson’s romance was in full swing.
Honorable Mention: Thomas Barrow and Jimmy Kent, Downton Abbey
![](https://thumbs.gfycat.com/GrandioseSpectacularIguanodon-small.gif)
Thomas really didn’t have many friends, did he? I mean, yeah. Most of that was his fault for being a terrible person most of the time, but any time someone did show him kindness he proved he was capable of friendship. Jimmy and Thomas had a rough start, but when they became real friends and Jimmy overcame his initial homophobia it seemed like they were building towards a romance. Jimmy very much had the vibe of a closeted guy overperforming hyper-masculinity. He really only ever hit on girls in front of Thomas or to prove he was straight. He wasn’t interested in Ivy until after the kiss incident, and I very much read him as overcompensating. Except apparently he wasn’t and there was never anything legitimately romantic between the two of them. Jimmy had an affair with his old (female) boss and got fired and that was the last he and Thomas saw of each other. I just wanted Thomas to be happy, okay? And Jimmy seemed like the best/only plausible partner for him.
Alexis Rose and Ted Mullens, Schitt’s Creek
Why didn’t they end up together? After dating on and off for most of the show’s run, Ted got his dream job in the Galapagos. Alexis seriously considered moving there with them, but after dating long distance for a while, it became obvious that—despite their love for each other—their lives were at a crossroads and in the long run they’d both be happier if they split.
What’s their deal? Alexis was a spoiled rich girl who moved into Ted’s town. Ted, a vet, was the most financially viable romantic interest there so Alexis decided he’d be a fun boyfriend for what she saw as a brief stay until her family’s finances improved. At first, it was a wildly unsuccessful relationship. Alexis saw Ted as a stopgap and was more attracted to another guy. But as their acquaintance deepened (after a few unfortunate proposals of marriage) and Alexis developed as a person, the two actually became very close friends. Admittedly Ted always did more for Alexis than vice versa, like when he hired her as his receptionist when she desperately needed a job but lacked all the qualifications, but eventually the two came to truly love each other deeply. One of the cutest moments of the entire show was when Alexis adopted Ted’s habit of making cringey but adorable animal puns. That moment made them feel like soulmates.
Unlike pretty much every other couple on this list, I’m actually okay with this breakup. The best relationships are the ones where the two people make each other better. A lot of TV romances tie into the individual characters’ arcs, and the relationship is kind of a culmination of the character growth on both sides and/or each partner gives the other something they’ve been searching for. In those cases, when the relationship doesn’t work out, something feels wrong. But with Ted and Alexis, the breakup is actually good writing. Not all couples live happily-ever-after, and even though Ted is a big part of Alexis’ development (love that journey for her) and she for him, their growth was demonstrated more by their mature breakup than it would have been by a continued relationship. Alexis was, at the beginning of Schitt’s Creek, defined by her relationships with men, so letting her step out on her own without the safety net of a boyfriend was really the best decision for her.
I still think she and Ted are adorable, though.
Darryl Whitefeather and Josh Wilson, Crazy Ex-Girlfriend
![](https://tv-fanatic-res.cloudinary.com/iu/s--08ZqLadn--/t_slideshow/cs_srgb,f_auto,fl_strip_profile.lossy,q_auto:420/v1470966605/slides/1997/white-josh-feather-giving-relationship-advice.gif)